Beginning of NATO’s End? German Troops will move from Turkey


Germany is set to pull its troops out of the Incirlik air base in Turkey after Ankara failed to grant German lawmakers the right to visit Bundeswehr troops stationed there.

The German cabinet is due to approve the decision on Wednesday, after a meeting between Foreign Minister Sigmar Gabriel and his Turkish counterpart Mevlet Cavosuglu failed to find a resolution to the dispute.

“Turkey has made clear that, for domestic reasons, it cannot approve visits of all lawmakers. I regret that, but Turkey must understand that for domestic political reasons, we must transfer German soldiers out of Incirlik,” Gabriel told a press briefing on Monday.

Cavosuglu told the press conference that German lawmakers are allowed to visit the NATO base at Konya, but still can’t go to Incirlik, which is mainly used by the Turkish and US air forces.

“At the moment, there aren’t the conditions for a visit to Incirlik,” the Turkish Foreign Minister said.

Prior to the crisis talks, Cavosuglu had called Germany’s approach to relations with Turkey “troubling,” and said Ankara might reconsider its ban on visitation if Berlin changes its stance.

“It is not possible to open the Incirlik base for a visit, but we might reconsider the decision in the future if we see ‘positive steps’ from Germany,” Cavosuglu said, the Daily Sabah reported.

The conflict over German access to the base re-ignited last month after a group of German lawmakers were refused permission to visit troops at Incirlik, which is home to some 260 German soldiers as well as Tornado jets and aircraft tankers.

The German military arrived at Incirlik in January 2016 after the Bundestag approved non-combat roles for German aircraft and service personnel in US-led anti-Daesh operations. These include reconnaissance missions and refueling for coalition aircraft.

German Bundestag deputies attempted to visit soldiers at Incirlik on May 15, but were refused permission. Ankara’s refusal was retaliation at Germany’s decision in early May to grant asylum to 414 Turkish soldiers, diplomats, judges and government employees who sought refuge in Germany following last July’s failed military coup.

It is the second time that the Turkish government has punished Germany by refusing access to Incirlik, following an incident in June 2016 when Bundestag deputies were denied entry after they passed a resolution recognizing the 1915 Armenian Genocide.

In the aftermath of the latest aborted visit, Defense Minister Ursula von der Leyen visited Jordan’s Al Azraq air base, and commented on her “positive” impression about the base as an alternative to Incirlik.

On Monday, von der Leyen said that the Bundeswehr has received approval about the transfer from King Abdullah of Jordan and is “ready” to move troops and around 10,000 tons of equipment.

“Of course, this means a pause in our flight missions in the fight against Daesh,” the Minister said, adding that the tankers should be ready to fly again in two to three weeks, and the Tornados in two to three months.

In September 2016, the German defense ministry budgeted for the investment of €58 million ($65 million) in military infrastructure at Incirlik, including €26 million on an airfield for German Tornado reconnaissance aircraft and €30 million on a Luftwaffe command post.

According to the German news website Heise, the €58 million has already been disbursed to the Turkish government and Turkish construction companies, which contributed to Berlin’s reluctance to leave the base.

Nevertheless, there is cross-party support for the decision to leave Incirlik.

“This is not a decision against Turkey, this is rather more a decision for our constitution and our soldiers,” SPD party chairman in the Bundestag, Thomass Opperman, said last week.

“I regret Turkey’s decision, especially since it contradicts NATO values. The Federal Government cannot allow the Turkish attitude to deprive it of its rights. The transfer from Incirlik is therefore logical,” CDU chairman in the Bundestag Franz Josef Jung stated on Monday.

  • jj

    Turkey should have the right not to indefinitely host foreign armies. I don’t think Germany has a right to throw a fit over it. Germany played a major role in Turkey’s Armenian genocide as well. Did Germany recognize its role in it?

  • Billy

    I don’t think Turkey considers itself part of NATO… they are now in it to pull their weight in any direction they want, they can veto anything and everything… So from that angle, they are in.
    NATO is an anti Russian alliance… what people forget is that it wasn’t Germany alone that attacked Russia… Over 100,000 Romanians and 50,000 idiot Bulgarians took part in it, not to mention Norwegians, Spanish, French, Croatians, Hungarians… it was almost an all out European attack. NATO is working on a similar attack, hoping they’ll be more successful this time around.

    • jj

      The French attacked Russia in WWII?

      • Billy

        There were French that went to fight Russia, yes.

        But history books today, focus on Germany, but once again, with few minor exceptions, almost all of Europe attacked Russia, all the quisling Governments sent their soldiers.

        Why do you think our retarded Government is sending soldiers to Afghanistan? Well, it was similar in 1941…

        • jj

          The Romanians are still generally hateful of Russians today. I think they also associate their difficult communist time with Russia even though most all the Soviet leaders were non-Russians who actually suppressed and harmed Russia and Russians, while aiding the non-Russians.

  • Goran Stavreski

    Here is what I know of WWII, from my grandpa who lost three brothers in it.
    The Germans never bothered anyone in Macedonia, if you don’t shoot at them, they simply moved on. Occasionally, they asked for food. The Italians, or as my grandpa called them ‘the biggest pussies” on the planet, would run for miles at a sound of a fart.

    He lost his brothers outside of Macedonia, in Croatia, were killed by Croatian ustash who fought with the Germans against the partisans.
    Most Macedonians died outside of Macedonia.

    Vanco Mihajlov wanted partisans to support the Bulgarians and the Germans, but then changed his mind when it became painfully obvious the Russians were coming.

    So our history is one of complete idiocy and Macedonians dying for someone else, because we’ve never had good leadership… and very likely never will.

    • jj

      “So our history is one of complete idiocy and Macedonians dying for someone else, because we’ve never had good leadership”

      But couldn’t the individuals have resisted? Were his brothers forcefully recruited into the Partisan units or did they decide to join up on their own?